arrow-left arrow-right caret-down check chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right close external facebook home images instagram linkedin marker menu minus page pinterest plus scroll search twitter youtube Skip to content

Shullsburg Creamery

Wisconsin Cheese the way it was made when our grandfathers were around. Small batch, hands on cheese mastery. One of a kind. We bring brand promise to our loyal customers. That is what we are the most proud of.
Shullsburg Creamery, is arguably the best cheese being made in Wisconsin or anywhere for that matter. We slowly make it right. Wisconsin Cheese is the only category that sells if it is good. Colby, Cheddar, Colby jack, Monterey Jack, Colby Longhorn, Colby Jack Longhorn, Swiss, Baby Swiss, Curd, Hot Pepper cheese, Cheese-n-Salami, Provolone Mozzarella Muenster, and Mild Brick American Cheese. This is our area of expertise.

REAL® Dairy Products

Butter
  1. Shullsburg Creamery Butter-Salted
  2. Shullsburg Creamery Sweet Cream Butter-Salted
Cheese/Cheese Products
  1. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese Curd-Chipotle Peppers
  2. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese Curd-Dill
  3. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese Curd-Garlic & Chive
  4. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese Curd-Jalapeno Peppers
  5. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese Curd-Mixed
  6. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese Curd-White
  7. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese Curd-Yellow
  8. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese-Fancy Shredded
  9. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese-Mild, Aged, Sliced
  10. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese-Mild, Sliced
  11. Shullsburg Cheddar Cheese-Shredded
  12. Shullsburg Colby Jack Cheese-Peppered, Sliced
  13. Shullsburg Colby Jack Cheese-Shredded
  14. Shullsburg Colby Jack Cheese-Sliced
  15. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Cheddar Bacon
  16. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Extra Hot Horseradish
  17. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Garden Vegetable
  18. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Garlic
  19. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Horseradish
  20. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Jalapeno Peppers
  21. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Onion
  22. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Port Wine
  23. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Sharp Cheddar
  24. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Smokey Cheddar
  25. Shullsburg Cold Pack Cheese Spread-Swiss Almond
  26. Shullsburg Creamery Hot Pepper Cheese-Sliced
  27. Shullsburg Creamery Muenster Cheese-Sliced
  28. Shullsburg Creamery Provolone Cheese-Sliced
  29. Shullsburg Creamery Swiss Cheese-Baby, Sliced
  30. Shullsburg Creamery Swiss Cheese-Mild, Sliced
  31. Shullsburg Mexican Cheese-Shredded
  32. Shullsburg Mozzarella Cheese-Shredded
Sour Cream
  1. Shullsburg Creamery Sour Cream-Acidified and Natural Culture Added

Looking to get listed in our
REAL® Guide? Apply to use the
REAL® Seal here.

Get Certified